1.2K views
24 comments

made a cherry cheese cake, the crust is tasting like soap. No other words to describe it.

So I wasted all the ingredients making the cheesecake, & was embarrassed on serving it to my guests. Never had that happen before using the crust. A picture wouldnt show what it taste like.

The crust look fine, just the taste was like soap. There is nothing more to say, I would just like all my money back of about 12.00 I had in the making of a wasted cherry cheese cake.

Reason of review: just disappointed in product.

Monetary Loss: $12.

Preferred solution: Let the company propose a solution.

Location: Arcadia, Florida

Do You Have Something To Say ?
Write a review

Comments

chat-icon

Please avoid publishing any personal information and promotional content

You will be automatically registered on our site. Username and password will be sent to you via email.
Post Comment
Wynter Lvx

This just happened to me! Soap/gasoline flavored keebler Graham cracker pie crust!

I'm so embarrassed that my guests had that in their mouth! The ingredients and money and time wasted too!

I wish they would address this issue! I'm so mad!

Guest

My mom just had the same problem but with Honey Maid Graham Cracker Crumbs. Cheese cake crusted tasted terrible, hard to describe just how bad.

This was a brand new box as she had a similar problem at Christmas last year (2018) possibly with a different brand) An internet search indicated that Honey Maid had a similar problem in 2016 that was traced back to rancid oil.

Not sure whose crackers to trust now. Best suggestion is to smell the contents immediately after opening and sample a small amount before using.

Jonel Wsf

We just made a quick blueberry pie and it tastes like soap. Itโ€™s not the berries at all.

The crust part tastes like perfume to me and my husband said soap. We had to throw away the pie.

Brystol Fcs

Really weird I found this post. Searched to see if anyone else posted on a bad taste.

Just had a shortbread crust pie. Crust has a funny taste. Everyone explains it differently.

But we think rancid oil maybe. But definitely tastes like a chemical or something nasty.

Guest

Just made a lemon pudding pie. Noticed the smell when I baked the crust.

Yuckkk. Wasted pie.

Guest

I made chocolate pudding pie for my nephews for Christmas using the mini crusts. THEY TASTED LIKE SOAP. Ruined dessert.

Guest

Thanksgiving chocolate cream pie... Crust tasted like soap.

Inedible. Gross

Machele Imf

I suspect the foreign workers Keebler hired or the foreign country it got some of it's ingredients from. Obviously, something happened during the production process. Best to avoid Keebler in the future.

Guest

Oh my! I just made this cherry recipe thatโ€™s on the back of the Keebler label and same thing! The crust tastes like soap!!!!!

Guest

2/17/18, Glad I found this, I thought I was crazy for thinking these taste like that after-vomit breath, or soapy, as others have mentioned. Even more diappointing this isn't a 1 bad batch thing.

Guest

I made a vanilla custard pie and couldn't understand why it tasted like soap. After tasting the filling and topping and crust individually turns out to be the crust.

Yuk! Such a waste of ingredients and my time.

Guest

I made 4 cheesecakes for Christmas dinner and my family tried it and it tasted like soapy vomit. I was pissed off and disappointed.

I pride myself on my cooking and to serve my family this disaster was devastating.

I don't think I will ever buy graham cracker crust or graham crackers again. I'm so pissed off .

Guest

I bought one instead of making my own and when I opened it , it was cracked and broken. Had no choice but to use it. Will find out tomorrow if it tastes okay.

Guest

Nasty! Great Key Lime Pie ruined.

Keebler 9" graham cracker crust tastes like coconut hand soap. Purchased and used today.

10-22-2017 Winn Dixie St. Simons Island GA.

Guest

Yukkk the same thing just happened to me tonight...threw whole pie out and other our crusts we had. .can't get this taste out if my mouth..thought it was me so I googled it nd found this post

Guest

I've had the same experience with both the regular size crusts and mini crusts within the past couple of years, and both were purchased at different stores. I thought my tastebuds were overly sensitive the first time, or that I'd accidentally stored them too close to my laundry room, but when I tasted the mini ones, same thing.

I hate to think that I've just wasted all of these so maybe I'll just have to eat the pudding filling out of each one. For reference, I'm located in Southern CA.

Guest

i too just had the same in wellington fl

Guest

I just bought the 6 pack mini keebler pie crusts and sure enough...tastes like bitter soap. So i googled it...and others too have experienced it.

K16854* *** NLI# 09700

sku 0 789******* *

purchased 3/6/2017 at publix wellington fl

Guest

Just made a chocolate pie in a prepared graham cracker pie crust. The crust tasted just like "soap".

Horrible. I just threw everything away.

Guest

Same exact thing just happened to me. My mother used those exact words "soap" and I agreed.

Who wants to eat soap! Thoroughly disgusted.

View more comments (4)

Keebler Reviews

  1. 219 reviews
  2. 61 reviews
  3. 41 reviews
  4. 40 reviews
  5. 25 reviews
Keebler reviews